Testimonial 9 - Herman Menderchuck

I've never considered myself religious ever since I can consider myself to have started developing my own opinion. My parents were loosely Christian, but we only ever went to church when we were visiting the grandparents or when they were visiting us. Still, I was raised to at least in theory believe in God, and specifically the Christian God.

The first recollection I have of realizing something was wrong was when I first legitimately considered the question "where did God come from?" I was probably 13 years old and assumed somebody would have an answer to this fairly basic question. I posed it to my Mom and she had nothing to give me. I asked other people with a fair amount of shame, assuming that I was either not supposed to be asking these things, or at the least, I was stupid for not knowing the answer. It didn't take long to realize that this was, in fact, a GOOD question to ask, and that began the unraveling of the tall tales I'd been fed. Unlike Santa Claus, for which I have no recollection of the time the news was broken to me, this one seemed a bit more important, even in my barely adolescent mind, since the stakes were quite a bit higher. I mean I would still get presents under the tree, so no big loss there, but on the other hand, there was the vague understanding that I was going to die and NOT come back to life.

Well, I sat on that one and developed it as more exotic modes of thought were gradually introduced as they usually are through circles of friends who are also discovering that the world's a bit more complex than it first seemed. Since Al Gore was still in the process of inventing the Internet at this point, I didn't have it as an advantage, and likely gave religion the benefit of the doubt for a much longer time than I otherwise would have, had information been this readily available and in such volumes. I stayed agnostic with a fair leaning towards there not being any sort of divine being at all to worry about.

More recently, and as a result of my participation on these types of forums, I can say I side with the atheists. I can even call myself an atheist more readily than anything else, but save that label for special occasions. I think this mindset is fairly typical of non-believers, and unfortunately might contribute heavily to our inability to mobilize. The mob mentality of religion is quite possibly the thing I dislike the most about religion, and it definitely contributes to my reluctance to operate under a label- 

1) Because it implies to outsiders that I have a pre-defined set of beliefs that they can assume above and beyond my lack of belief in God (i.e. they think I can prove this, a common misconception), 

2) Because it inhibits the fluctuation of beliefs as they change through time- in other words, if I change my stance to anti-theist or what have you, I would almost feel the need to make an announcement, which doesn't appeal to me, and 

3) It feels silly to HAVE to identify myself as not believing in a thoroughly ridiculous set of ideas.

It could just be the mindset common in non-believers that we dislike conformity and strive to avoid it even when we agree. We may feel that even labeling ourselves as atheists at all gives far more credibility to religion than it deserves (which is none). But there is a strong sense that non-believers are not easy to unite in any meaningful way. That seems to have overtaken my other motives in participating in these forums as my main interest- i.e. how to participate in this issue and come to grips with the fact I must acknowledge religion's influence, and in so doing, give it some air of validation.

This is roughly where I currently stand and I expect I'll have to change this stance in some part as the years go on. One thing I don't expect, however, is that my distaste for religion will diminish.

Discuss this testimonial